Willow Tree Nativity Guide: Which Set to Start With and What Fits

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Product details on this page come from the maker or the Amazon listing, checked on November 18, 2026. We have not handled or tested these items, and we don’t list prices because they change. Check the listing before you buy.

The short answer: Willow Tree makes three nativity collections in three sizes, and add-on pieces only match the collection they were made for. Most people start with the classic 6-piece Nativity (tallest figure 9.5 inches), because it has the most add-ons: the Three Wisemen, shepherds, animals, a wooden crèche and a star backdrop. Choose The Christmas Story for a large, 14.5-inch display, or The Holy Family for a small, 7.5-inch one.

Willow Tree figures are designed by artist Susan Lordi, who hand-carves the original of each piece in her Kansas City studio. The pieces are cast from her carvings and painted by hand, and they have no facial features: expression comes from “a tilt of the head, placement of the hands, a turn of the body,” as the company puts it.

Which Willow Tree nativity should you start with?

Collection Size Starter set Made to go with it
Nativity (classic, introduced 2000) Tallest figure 9.5 in 6-piece Nativity: Mary with Jesus, Joseph, shepherd, donkey, 2 sheep Three Wisemen, Shepherd and Stable Animals, Crèche, Metal Star Backdrop, Little Shepherdess, Zampognaro
The Christmas Story (large) Tallest figure 14.5 in The Christmas Story: Joseph and seated Mary, 2 pieces Gentle Animals of the Stable; designed to sit on the base of the Sanctuary backdrop
The Holy Family (small) 7.5 in, one piece The Holy Family figure, or the complete small-scale set of 6 Sheltering Animals; Shelter for the Holy Family (pierced metal)
Willow Tree 6-piece Nativity

Willow Tree 6-piece Nativity

Good for: most first-time buyers

Six hand-painted resin figures, the tallest 9.5 inches: Joseph with a wooden staff, kneeling Mary holding the baby Jesus, a shepherd carrying a lamb, a donkey and two sheep. Willow Tree introduced it in 2000. The enclosure card reads “Behold the awe and wonder of the Christmas Story.”

Willow Tree The Christmas Story

Willow Tree The Christmas Story

Good for: a large display on a sideboard or in a church entry

Two hand-painted resin figures, the tallest 14.5 inches: Joseph standing with a staff and Mary seated on a rock. Willow Tree’s listing says they fit with the three Gentle Animals of the Stable on the base of the Sanctuary backdrop.

Willow Tree The Holy Family (small scale), set of 6

Willow Tree The Holy Family (small scale), set of 6

Good for: a small shelf or a first apartment

The 7.5-inch Holy Family figure plus the four Sheltering Animals (donkey, two sheep, goat) and the pierced-metal Shelter backdrop, all in the same small scale.

Will Willow Tree pieces fit together?

Only within a collection. Willow Tree’s own FAQ says the Three Wisemen, Shepherd and Stable Animals and Ox and Goat are designed for the classic 6-piece Nativity and Crèche, and “will look very odd if placed in The Christmas Story.” They are also “way too large” for The Holy Family. The large collection has its own animals (Gentle Animals of the Stable, proportioned for the 14.5-inch figures), and the small one has the Sheltering Animals, scaled to the 7-inch Mary and Joseph.

If you are buying a piece as a gift, ask which collection the person owns, or check the figure heights on their pieces first.

Willow Tree nativity add-on pieces compared

Sizes are from Willow Tree’s Amazon listings.

Piece Collection Details More
The Three Wisemen Nativity (classic) 3 figures; tallest 8.5 in Our page
Shepherd and Stable Animals Nativity (classic) Shepherd with goat, 2 sheep, camel; tallest 7 in Our page
Crèche backdrop Nativity (classic) Wood, 17 x 20 x 11.5 in; folds flat —
Metal Star Backdrop Nativity (classic) 7 metal stars on a weighted base; 13.5 in —
Little Shepherdess Nativity (classic) or alone Girl with 2 sheep; 5 in —
Zampognaro (shepherd with bagpipe) Nativity (classic) Shepherd with goat and bagpipe; 9 in —
Gentle Animals of the Stable The Christmas Story Donkey and 2 sheep; tallest 5.5 in Our page
Sheltering Animals The Holy Family Goat, donkey, 2 sheep; tallest 3 in Our page
Starry Night Nativity Stands alone Triptych 8.5 x 8 x 2 in; opens to 16 in Our page
Willow Tree The Three Wisemen

Willow Tree The Three Wisemen

Good for: adding the kings to the classic Nativity

Three hand-painted resin figures, kneeling, bowing and standing, each carrying a metal vial or box. The tallest is 8.5 inches. The enclosure card reads “They followed a star and found the Light of the World.”

Willow Tree Shepherd and Stable Animals

Willow Tree Shepherd and Stable Animals

Good for: filling out the classic Nativity

Four hand-painted resin pieces, the tallest 7 inches: a kneeling shepherd with a crook and an attached goat, two sheep and a camel lying down.

Willow Tree Crèche

Willow Tree Crèche

Good for: a backdrop for the classic Nativity

A hand-painted wooden stable, 17 inches high, 20 inches wide and 11.5 inches deep, with an antiqued blue-gray finish. It folds flat for storage, and its two bases fit together for a tiered display.

Is the Starry Night Nativity part of a set?

No. The Starry Night Nativity is a single piece: an 8.5-inch resin box with hinged doors that open to 16 inches, revealing the Nativity carved in bas-relief under a starry sky, with applied gold leaf. It can stand on a table or hang on a wall from two keyhole hangers, and it weighs 5.5 pounds. It works well when there is no room for a full set. Read our Starry Night Nativity page or see it on Amazon.

Other Willow Tree pieces often given at Christmas include Angel of Mine, an 8.5-inch figure holding an infant (our page), and the Holy Family figure on its own.

How do you care for Willow Tree figures?

  • Dust only. Use a dry, soft brush or cloth. The paint is water-based and applied in thin, rubbed-off layers, so water and cleaners can damage it.
  • Keep them indoors. Willow Tree says weather can wear, streak or fade the paint.
  • Keep the boxes. Each piece ships in a fitted box, which is the safest way to store it after Christmas. Willow Tree notes the inner bag protects the finish from scratches.
  • Small breaks: Willow Tree suggests a very small amount of epoxy along the break.

How can you tell a Willow Tree piece is real?

Look at the back. Willow Tree says an authentic piece has “©Susan Lordi” and a date carved into it. Buying from the Willow Tree store on Amazon or a known retailer also helps.

Frequently asked questions

What are Willow Tree figures made of?

Resin. Willow Tree says its resin is about 51% calcium carbonate and 49% polyresin, chosen because it captures every knife mark of Susan Lordi’s carved originals. Each piece is then painted by hand.

Where are Willow Tree figures made?

Susan Lordi carves each original in her studio in Kansas City, Missouri. The originals are sent to a factory in China, where they are cast in resin and hand-painted, according to Willow Tree.

Do the Willow Tree Three Wisemen fit The Christmas Story or The Holy Family?

No. Willow Tree says the Three Wisemen, the Shepherd and Stable Animals and the Ox and Goat are made for the classic 6-piece Nativity. They look too small with The Christmas Story and too large with The Holy Family.

Can I display Willow Tree outside?

Willow Tree advises against it. The paint is water-based and applied in thin layers, so weather can wear it off, streak it or fade the color.

How do I clean Willow Tree figures?

Dust them with a dry, soft brush or cloth. Don’t use water, a wet cloth or cleaning solvents, because the paint is water-based.

How can I tell if a Willow Tree piece is authentic?

Willow Tree says an authentic piece has “©Susan Lordi” and a date carved into the back.

Sources