Nativity Sets: How to Choose One, and How to Set It Up

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Product details on this page come from the maker or the Amazon listing, checked on November 18, 2026. We have not handled or tested these items, and we don’t list prices because they change. Check the listing before you buy.

The short answer: pick a nativity set by where it will stand and who will handle it. For a mantel or table, a resin, porcelain or wood set with figures about 5 to 10 inches tall is the usual choice. Homes with toddlers do better with a plastic or wooden play set. A yard display needs material the maker rates for outdoor use, plus stakes. If you want to add shepherds, kings and animals over the years, start with a collection sold in a fixed scale, such as Fontanini’s 5-inch line or the Willow Tree Nativity, so new pieces match.

What should you look for in a nativity set?

  • Indoor or outdoor. Most figurine sets are indoor-only. Willow Tree, for one, warns that weather can wear off or streak its water-based paint. Yard sets are usually PVC, plastic or a lighted metal frame.
  • Scale. If you plan to add pieces, stay inside one maker’s scale. Willow Tree says its Three Wisemen and stable animals are sized for the classic 6-piece Nativity and “will look very odd” with its larger Christmas Story figures. Fontanini sells 5-inch pieces, such as the Kings set and a wooden stable, to build out the same scene.
  • Material. Resin and porcelain show fine detail but can chip if dropped. Fontanini’s Amazon listings describe its figures as a durable polymer. Olive wood sets are carved, so each one varies a little. Play sets are plastic or wood.
  • What is included. A “Holy Family” set is Mary, Joseph and the Infant Jesus only. Fuller sets add shepherds, kings, an angel, animals and a stable. Count the pieces on the listing, since photos often show add-ons sold separately.
  • One piece or many. A one-piece scene is quick to set up and has nothing to lose. Separate figures let you arrange the scene and add pieces through the season.

Nativity sets compared

Sizes and materials below are as stated by the maker or on the Amazon listing.

Set Good for Material Size What’s included
Willow Tree 6-piece Nativity Classic indoor set you can add to Hand-painted resin Tallest figure 9.5 in Mary with Jesus, Joseph, shepherd, donkey, 2 sheep
Fontanini Classic Holy Family, 3-piece Starting a collection Hand-painted; made in Italy 5-inch scale Mary, Joseph, Infant Jesus; story card
Zuluf small olive wood nativity Small shelf or desk Olive wood, carved in Bethlehem About 4.7 in Mary, Joseph, Jesus in a bark-roof crèche
Fisher-Price Little People Nativity Toddlers Plastic About 6.75 x 13.2 x 7.5 in Stable, manger, 12 figures, 5 play pieces; light-up star
Melissa & Doug wooden nativity Children 4 and up Wood About 15.7 x 11.5 in boxed 4-piece stable, 11 figures
Tales of Glory (BibleToys) nativity Children 3 and up Plastic toy figures 18 pieces Figures, stable and a mini storybook (English and Spanish)
FrontYard Originals outdoor Holy Family Yard display Waterproof PVC; made in USA 48 in tall x 50 in wide Holy Family silhouette and yard stake
Best Choice Products 6 ft lighted nativity Lighted yard display Steel frame, LED lights (plug-in) 72 x 72 in arch Arch with star and 2D Holy Family; stakes
Nambé Holiday 4-piece Nativity Modern look Nambé alloy figures, acacia wood crèche Crèche 8.5 in high x 10 in wide Mary, Joseph, Jesus, crèche
Willow Tree Starry Night Nativity One piece, wall or table Resin with gold leaf 8.5 x 8 x 2 in; opens to 16 in Bas-relief triptych
Comfy Hour 12.5-inch Holy Family scene No loose pieces Hand-painted polyresin 12.5 in long One piece: Holy Family, angel, wise men, shepherds

What is the best kind of outdoor nativity set?

Look for three things on the listing: material rated for weather, a way to anchor it, and, if it lights up, lights meant for outdoor use. A flat or 2D design is lighter and stores flat; a molded set looks fuller from the street but takes more storage space. Measure your spot first, since many yard sets are 4 to 6 feet tall.

FrontYard Originals All-Weather Outdoor Holy Family

FrontYard Originals All-Weather Outdoor Holy Family

Good for: a simple unlit yard silhouette

The listing describes waterproof PVC plastic, made and shipped in the USA, about 48 inches tall and 50 inches wide, with a yard stake. It says it will not delaminate, warp or fade from weather, and needs some easy assembly.

Best Choice Products 6 ft Lighted Outdoor Nativity Scene

Best Choice Products 6 ft Lighted Outdoor Nativity Scene

Good for: a lighted arch scene seen from the street

A 72-inch arch topped with the star of Bethlehem frames a 2D Holy Family. The listing lists 170 LED lights, a plug-in power source, a steel frame, ground stakes and zip ties. The semi-flat pieces stack for storage.

What is a good small nativity set?

For a shelf, desk or windowsill, look for figures under about 8 inches, or a one-piece scene. Small sets also suit apartments and care-home rooms where space is tight.

Zuluf Small Olive Wood Nativity Set

Zuluf Small Olive Wood Nativity Set

Good for: a small, natural-wood scene from the Holy Land

The listing describes a 4.7-inch scene hand-carved from Bethlehem olive wood, with Mary, Joseph and the baby Jesus in a crèche with a bark roof. It says the sets are made in Jerusalem and Bethlehem by local Christian artisans and come with a certificate of authenticity.

Willow Tree The Holy Family

Willow Tree The Holy Family

Good for: a small Willow Tree scene

One 7.5-inch hand-painted resin piece showing Joseph standing beside Mary, who holds the Infant Jesus. Willow Tree sells small-scale animals and a shelter made to fit it. See our Willow Tree nativity guide for how the three Willow Tree collections differ.

Comfy Hour 6-inch Holy Family Figurine

Comfy Hour 6-inch Holy Family Figurine

Good for: a single small figure for a mantel or desk

A one-piece, hand-painted polyresin figure of Mary, Joseph and the Christ Child, about 6 inches tall, for indoor display.

What nativity set is best for kids?

Choose a set made as a toy, and check the age range on the listing. Resin and porcelain figurines are decorations, not toys, so keep them out of reach of small children. A play set lets children tell the Christmas story with their hands, which a breakable set can’t do.

Fisher-Price Little People Nativity Set with Music & Lights

Fisher-Price Little People Nativity Set with Music & Lights

Good for: toddlers

The listing gives a recommended age of 12 months to 5 years. It includes a stable, manger, 12 figures including the baby Jesus, and 5 play pieces. Pressing the angel on the stable roof lights the star and plays “Away in a Manger.”

Melissa & Doug Classic Wooden Christmas Nativity Set

Melissa & Doug Classic Wooden Christmas Nativity Set

Good for: children 4 to 8 who like wooden toys

A wooden set with a four-piece stable that assembles easily and 11 wooden figures. The listing says it includes a retelling of the Christmas story.

Tales of Glory (BibleToys) Nativity Set

Tales of Glory (BibleToys) Nativity Set

Good for: a first play set with a storybook

Eighteen pieces for children 3 and up: Joseph, Mary, the baby Jesus in the manger, three kings, two angels, two shepherds, a camel, donkey, two sheep, a stable, a tree and a hay barrel, with a mini storybook in English and Spanish.

What are some unique nativity sets?

Nambé Holiday 4-Piece Nativity Scene

Nambé Holiday 4-Piece Nativity Scene

Good for: a modern, minimal look

Metal figures of Mary, Joseph and the baby Jesus in Nambé’s alloy, with a carved wooden crèche. The listing credits designer Todd Weber and gives the crèche as 8.5 inches high and 10 inches wide, with Joseph at 7 inches.

Willow Tree Starry Night Nativity

Willow Tree Starry Night Nativity

Good for: a nativity that hangs on a wall or stands on a table

Willow Tree describes an 8.5 x 8 x 2 inch resin box whose hinged doors open to 16 inches, with the Nativity carved in bas-relief inside and applied gold leaf. It weighs 5.5 pounds and has two keyhole hangers.

Comfy Hour 12.5-inch Holy Family Nativity Scene

Comfy Hour 12.5-inch Holy Family Nativity Scene

Good for: a full scene with no loose pieces

One hand-painted polyresin piece, 12.5 inches long, showing the Holy Family under a golden arch with an angel, the three wise men and shepherds.

Other ideas on this site: a Jim Shore rotating nativity, a musical nativity cross with an LED light, a nativity cross-stitch kit for someone who likes to make things, and nativity Advent candle holders that count down the four Sundays before Christmas.

How do you set up a nativity scene?

There is no single right way. Pope Francis wrote that “it does not matter how the nativity scene is arranged: it can always be the same or it can change from year to year.” This order works well for most sets:

  1. Choose a steady spot. A mantel, sideboard or table, away from heat and out of reach of small children and pets if the figures are breakable. Keep lit candles at least 12 inches from anything that can burn, as the National Fire Protection Association advises.
  2. Place the stable or backdrop first. Center it so the figures can be seen from the room.
  3. Set Mary and Joseph at the center, with the manger between them. Many families leave the manger empty until Christmas.
  4. Add the animals near the manger. In St. Francis’s first nativity scene, the Infant lay in the manger “with an ox and an ass standing by.”
  5. Put the shepherds and sheep to one side, and an angel or star above the stable.
  6. Bring in the Infant Jesus at Christmas and the three kings as Epiphany approaches, as Pope Francis describes.
  7. Bless it, if you like. The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) publishes a short Blessing of a Christmas Manger or Nativity Scene that a parent or another family member may lead at home.

Where did the nativity scene come from?

The custom of displaying figures of Christ’s birth traces to St. Francis of Assisi, who made a Christmas crèche for Christmas Eve of 1223, according to the USCCB. Pope Francis’s letter Admirabile signum tells the story: at Greccio, a small Italian town near Rieti, Francis asked a local man to prepare a manger with hay, an ox and a donkey, and friars and local families gathered there on Christmas night. The letter also notes that the Italian name for a nativity scene, presepe, comes from the Latin praesepium, “manger.”

Frequently asked questions

When should you set up a nativity scene?

Most families set it up in the days before Christmas. Pope Francis describes “the beautiful family tradition of preparing the nativity scene in the days before Christmas,” and the U.S. bishops’ blessing for a home nativity scene may be prayed on the Vigil of Christmas or at another suitable time.

When do you put baby Jesus in the manger?

Many families leave the manger empty and add the Infant Jesus at Christmas. Pope Francis writes that “when, at Christmas, we place the statue of the Infant Jesus in the manger, the nativity scene suddenly comes alive.” If your set’s baby Jesus is molded to Mary or the manger, you can simply display it as it is.

When do the wise men go in the nativity scene?

By custom the Three Kings are added as the feast of the Epiphany approaches, since they arrived after the birth. Some families place them across the room and move them closer each day.

Can an indoor nativity set go outside?

Usually not. Resin, porcelain and painted wood sets are made for indoor use. Willow Tree, for example, says its water-based paint may wear off, streak or fade if exposed to weather. For a yard, choose a set the listing describes as outdoor or weatherproof, and anchor it against wind.

What is the difference between a nativity set and a crèche?

They mean nearly the same thing. A crèche is a manger scene; the Italian word presepe comes from the Latin praesepium, meaning “manger.” In shopping, “crèche” is also used for the stable or backdrop piece sold on its own.

Sources